Book a Demo!
CoCalc Logo Icon
StoreFeaturesDocsShareSupportNewsAboutPoliciesSign UpSign In
Download
29548 views
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
okay i guess we're on the air now
14
15
16
right
17
18
19
uh i haven't had too much experience with uh judges and jurors
20
i've uh served on a jury one time and uh i think one of my concerns after that experience was
21
uh finding that there tend to be people in the jury that can't bring themselves to sentence someone
22
23
24
yes i i have my primary experience has been as uh an expert witness and and uh and two murder trials
25
26
27
28
29
um
30
31
32
and uh in each case it was a retrial and the sentencing was the same each time which happened in the state of Florida happened to be uh death
33
but in terms of i well the question also was in terms of mandatory sentencing or mandatory sentences for uh certain crimes
34
i think
35
depending on uh in certain crimes i think that they should be mandatory
36
for example uh armed robbery
37
uh if we have convicted i think uh plea bargaining should should be uh a thing of the past
38
um
39
certain types of uh
40
you know homicides
41
42
43
yeah i'm inclined to agree you do need a uh fixed and clear sentence there
44
45
46
yes in in homicides related to other than i guess what are called uh crimes of passion uh for example you know as you as you very well know
47
the great majority of homicides are
48
people murdering other people they know mostly people they know
49
50
51
yeah
52
53
54
so in those instances uh that's uh i think that there is some leeway there what was is interesting in this regard is the recent case in New Hampshire
55
56
57
yes
58
59
60
uh the schoolteacher
61
62
63
um-hum
64
65
66
and the life sentence uh she received
67
68
69
yeah i think that was a logical decision there
70
71
72
yes
73
and it came very quickly surprisingly
74
75
76
um-hum
77
78
79
uh i guess it was uh they brought in their verdict and sentence at the same time did they not
80
81
82
well well yeah i think they went back for a brief hearing on the sentence
83
84
85
um-hum
86
87
88
uh but that was that was fairly quick i think that is something that we need in this country i know the last time i was down in the Caribbean
89
uh we had visited the island of uh Saint Thomas which is American
90
and there were twenty three unsolved murders and nobody seem to be concerned about it
91
92
93
um
94
95
96
at the same time there was one unsolved murder on the island of Tortola and the whole island wanted to know when the hanging was going to take place
97
98
99
100
101
well in answer to you know answer to the question though i still think the sentencing should be in the hands of the jury even though as you say there are some
102
uh people who are reluctant i do not think again in the matter of uh uh that that judges should have the
103
uh
104
the upper hand or the only hand in that sense because i think if but i i've never served on a jury you probably know this better than i um
105
if the jury does their job and of course there are those on the jury that do not i'm sure but and ask the questions and
106
uh correctly and then one of things i've always wondered is uh the ability of jurors to to ask questions
107
108
109
i've never uh really been sure that a juror is entitled to ask a question
110
111
112
well that that that and that's an interesting point i've never i you know i've thought about it i've asked myself you know this question before
113
i've never taken the time to do the research to answer my own question but i know that at least during the deliberations of the jury
114
115
116
um-hum
117
118
119
they can ask questions
120
121
122
yes
123
i don't know whether they can go back and call witnesses for that though it's it depends on the the transcript they can ask uh points of order of law
124
125
126
127
128
um-hum
129
130
131
and maybe they can ask for a review of the transcript
132
133
134
right
135
136
137
uh but uh asking questions during the trial my experience as a juror uh well it was a traffic situation uh there were three points of law that had to be made
138
and the County Attorney did not make the points
139
140
141
um-hum
142
143
144
but the uh defendant took the stand on his own behalf
145
unfortunately he made the points himself in his own testimony
146
147
148
um-hum may i ask you a question
149
150
151
um-hum
152
153
154
why does your voice sound familiar to me
155
156
157
um
158
i work for E Systems
159
160
161
that's that's
162
probably why it does i work for GTE
163
164
165
okay
166
167
168
169
170
171
172
173
174
175
176
your your voice you know when uh i didn't recognize the name but the more i listen to your voice i
177
uh i know i have heard it somewhere
178
and i was trying to place where i had heard it that's very interesting but now back to the topic
179
180
181
okay
182
183
184
185
186
187
188
189
190
191
192
but uh because i work for
193
uh Hal Ammon
194
195
196
oh i know Hal Ammon quite well
197
198
199
yes i am on staff to Hal Ammon to GTE
200
201
202
okay
203
204
205
206
207
so
208
209
210
well say hi to Al or Hal the next time you see him
211
212
213
i
214
i will and which will probably be the uh Monday as a matter of fact
215
216
217
and tell
218
yeah well tell him that Bill Mayhood sell hi said hi
219
220
221
okay Bill i recognize the name now i and uh my name is Jim Moscow
222
223
224
okay
225
226
227
and uh so i've heard the name
228
and uh well back to the topic i guess we've talked long enough Bill
229
230
231
232
233
all right
234
235
236
but uh all right well thank you for calling and nice and have a good weekend
237
238
239
thank you good night
240
241
242
good-bye
243
244
245
246
247
248
249
250
251
252
253
254