Book a Demo!
CoCalc Logo Icon
StoreFeaturesDocsShareSupportNewsAboutPoliciesSign UpSign In
Download
29550 views
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
have you had any thoughts on this
14
15
16
well not really uh
17
i uh am of an age where i could have very well served in the military during the Vietnam era and i did not
18
19
20
um-hum
21
how old are you if i can ask
22
23
24
huh do what
25
26
27
how old are you
28
29
30
i'm will be forty nine in August
31
32
33
okay so we're about the same age
34
35
36
right uh
37
during that time i was in college and uh and also had some minor health problems that did keep me out of the out of the military or or help to keep me out anyway
38
39
40
um-hum
41
um-hum
42
43
44
but uh i'm not opposed to military service at all
45
46
47
yeah i think this is also a a broader scope i think uh they're talking about uh just service in general and um
48
49
50
51
52
uh
53
yeah
54
55
56
i i did a lot of this sort of thing in in college in the summers um i worked uh in uh Mexico doing community service for uh for two summers while i was in college and you know it was an incredibly worthwhile experience
57
58
59
um-hum
60
61
62
so in theory i'm am favor of this but on the other hand i'm an economist
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
and uh just like uh well the military has a tremendous uh you know responsibility for security and everything but there's also an equally tremendous budget
70
so i guess on the other hand as as as as good as this idea is it's got to be paid for
71
uh even though it's uh you know it it's it's never quite voluntary people have to be paid if they're asked to serve for a year in any capacity
72
so uh you know uh uh the idea's great where does the money come from
73
74
75
right i guess uh uh i've had i have had some thoughts in the past that uh this this service should not be uh performed for for areas that we don't need the service you know uh it's if it's uh
76
77
78
and
79
80
81
if it's voluntary service but it's being furnished by the government it should be to take the place of things that the government's doing already
82
83
84
um-hum
85
it should it it should or shouldn't it should um-hum
86
87
88
should right
89
so uh you know the the the voluntary service in the medical you know
90
91
92
but i don't think it was it was voluntary i think it was just the required year of required service there was nothing about voluntary
93
94
95
oh okay yeah then then then i guess that's you know uh-huh
96
97
98
that's why as an economist my my my ears perked up
99
100
101
102
103
104
105
uh at at any rate i guess my idea is that that
106
if we're going to replace if we're going to to institute this national service policy that that service policy should replace some other area
107
108
109
um-hum
110
uh-huh
111
112
113
where we're spending money uh you know uh you know eliminate eliminate some bureaucrats and let the let these national this national service take care of their job
114
115
116
and doing it at a less expensive rate then
117
uh-huh
118
of course you'll probably get another whole layer of bureaucracy running it
119
120
121
right and uh
122
123
124
i mean let's face it the military is probably one of the most bureaucratic agencies
125
126
127
right yeah
128
129
130
so i i i you know on the one hand my immediate reaction to it was oh it's wonderful you know i think people do owe their country something whether it
131
132
133
yeah
134
135
136
they serve in the military or for those who for for one reason or other can't want to serve in another area and have talents in another area
137
138
139
um-hum
140
141
142
great but then who pays and if they have to and they don't go into the labor the other labor force you're losing money in terms of taxing
143
144
145
yeah
146
right
147
148
149
from other jobs i mean so there's it's not it's not a real cut and dry
150
151
152
yeah i agree uh it and and it would uh would be nice if we could get some uh some multiple use out of this you know maybe uh
153
154
155
thing
156
um-hum
157
158
159
have the the military which is you know is is is a a a real drain financially on the country have the people that are in the military serve some other function you know instead instead of just military uh
160
161
162
um-hum um-hum
163
um-hum
164
and just marching around waiting for a war
165
166
167
right uh
168
169
170
yeah uh we did have something similar to a volunteer thing with uh which was volunteer although volunteer there was a minimum payment uh like Vista which was a domestic Peace Corps some time back
171
172
173
right
174
175
176
and probably coming from Texas you may have bumped into some of that
177
178
179
yeah i have seen uh you know i'm not really that you know that familiar with it i am aware that that that Vista and uh yeah
180
181
182
oh
183
yeah and i know the army what's the army has a corps of engineers
184
185
186
um-hum
187
188
189
which uh could probably be one of those areas that uh could be uh privatized or civilianized or whatever some of the areas there you know for domestic use
190
191
192
right
193
194
195
i've always wondered why the army corps of of engineers took care of floods you know in in certain areas why was
196
197
198
right it's well i guess uh in in in looking at that one reason that the army corps of engineers is that uh the military schools
199
200
201
um-hum
202
203
204
do have probably among the top engineering schools in the country uh
205
206
207
um-hum
208
but of course there are many private engineering schools that are absolutely superb
209
210
211
right
212
but uh but if if the government's going to uh to provide the service then government you know government trained people are are logical to do that uh
213
214
215
yeah they made
216
um-hum
217
yeah and of course back during the depression when the government started doing things like uh CCC the Civilian Conservation Corps
218
219
220
um-hum
221
222
223
so i uh you know there's a bit of a history of people serving the government and it doesn't have to be as the military you know if you go in just as a as an enlistee uh the wage isn't anything great
224
225
226
right
227
228
229
so if if you're asking for a year of service it doesn't have to be a wage comparable to the uh
230
if it's a required year it doesn't have to be a wage comparable to the private sector so it could be you know a wage enough to for have someone to live on to eat and if uh if in fact
231
232
233
right right yeah
234
235
236
so i guess that it a lot of thinking would have to be done if it were implemented
237
238
239
well and it
240
right it
241
yeah uh yeah i guess uh basically i'm you know i'm in favor of uh of the idea but
242
243
244
um-hum
245
246
247
i think that uh like you said a lot of thought needs to go into it just uh the financing and and the the uh the yeah
248
249
250
how it's administered and how you know uh just the who uh who who would be exempted because i'm sure there would be exemptions to it
251
252
253
but uh
254
but uh you know medical service and uh uh aid aid you know or or assistance for families and uh
255
256
257
uh
258
um-hum
259
260
261
oh even uh even uh running the uh the prison system might be a you know
262
a a an area that could run could taken be taken care of
263
264
265
um-hum or even or even doing paperwork for a police systems you know
266
267
268
right uh there's any number of things that the government's involved in
269
that uh
270
271
272
um-hum yeah
273
274
275
that this service could take care of
276
277
278
homeless homeless and all
279
280
281
282
283
yeah
284
285
286
i think they're going to cut us off
287
288
289
well i think that's my call waiting line ringing whoever that is will probably call back
290
291
292
oh oh
293
yeah but i think you know in terms of the the the crime pressing problems in the United States today that in terms of the homeless in terms of the state of the the state of the prisons
294
295
296
297
298
um-hum
299
300
301
um there're there're probably a lot of things that could be done uh on a volunteer basis so maybe they should do pilot projects to try it out to see how it works
302
303
304
right
305
yeah
306
right and uh just to see what uh what all could be done yeah it's uh nice talking to you too okay bye-bye
307
308
309
yeah well listen it was good talking with you
310
okay bye-bye
311
312
313
314
315
316
317
318
319
320
321
322