Book a Demo!
CoCalc Logo Icon
StoreFeaturesDocsShareSupportNewsAboutPoliciesSign UpSign In
Download
29548 views
1
2
3
4
5
I. The President's Approach - Building on Success
6
The President's Energy Plan includes a number of conservation,
7
advanced research and development, and other efforts that will
8
reduce electricity usage. Reducing the amount of electricity we use
9
and the amount of fuel needed to produce it are part of the answers
10
to the challenge of providing energy in an environmentally
11
responsible way.
12
The President's Energy Plan goes even further. The President has
13
directed me to develop proposed legislation that would
14
significantly reduce and cap NOx, SO2 and mercury emissions from
15
power generation. Such a program (with appropriate measures to
16
address local concerns) would provide significant health benefits
17
even as we increase electricity supplies. The proposed legislation
18
will:
19
20
21
-
22
establish reduction targets for emissions of SO2, NOx and
23
mercury,
24
25
26
-
27
phase in reductions over a reasonable time period,
28
similar to the successful Acid Rain Program established by the 1990
29
amendments to the Clean Air Act and to state programs,
30
31
32
-
33
provide regulatory certainty to allow utilities to make
34
modifications to their plants without fear of new litigation,
35
and
36
37
38
-
39
provide market-based incentives, such as emissions
40
trading, to help achieve the required reductions.
41
42
43
Nationwide reductions of the three emissions, SO2, NOx and
44
mercury, in an integrated approach would result in key benefits
45
including thousands of avoided premature deaths and aggravation of
46
respiratory and cardiovascular illness due to fine particles,
47
reduced hospitalization and emergency room visits due to fine
48
particles and continued exposure to ground-level ozone. It would
49
also address interstate transport issues as they relate to meeting
50
the new particulate matter and ozone air quality standards.
51
Visibility improvement would be anticipated over large areas
52
including national parks and wilderness areas and recovery of many
53
freshwater and coastal ecosystems would be likely. Public health
54
risks associated with mercury, particularly those posed to children
55
and women of child bearing age, may be reduced. This includes risks
56
of neurotoxic effects such as mental retardation, cerebral palsy,
57
difficulty speaking and hearing others, and other learning
58
disabilities. Currently, current forty plus states have fish
59
advisories; that number would be reduced.
60
The President's approach builds on the Acid Rain Program, which
61
provides a wonderful model for future programs. It has not only met
62
expectations, but exceeded them. Administering the Acid Rain
63
Program has been a cost-effective experience. The program will
64
achieve about 40% of the total emission reductions required under
65
the 1990 Clean Air Act Amendments at a low cost to industry and to
66
the government. The program is administered with a relatively small
67
staff relying on strong and state-of-the-art data tracking and
68
reporting capabilities.
69
When President George H.W. Bush signed the Clean Air Act
70
Amendments of 1990, it revolutionized clean air policy regarding
71
regional and national air pollution issues and drove environmental
72
protection in new directions. First, the President and Congress
73
designed the Acid Rain Program to focus on reducing the SO2
74
emissions that cause acid deposition and translated the emission
75
reduction goal into a nationwide cap on emissions from electric
76
generating sources. Second, Congress provided EPA with a tool to
77
achieve this reduction - - an innovative market-based allowance
78
trading program. This "cap and trade" approach provided greater
79
certainty that the emissions reductions would be achieved and
80
sustained while at the same time allowing industry unprecedented
81
flexibility in how to achieve the needed emission reductions. In
82
return for this flexibility, sources were to provide a full
83
accounting of their emissions through continuous monitoring and
84
reporting, and there would be consequences for failing to comply.
85
The objective was for sources to find the most cost-effective means
86
for limiting SO2 emissions and to be responsible for achieving
87
those emission reductions. There would be no government second
88
guessing and lengthy permit reviews.
89
Compliance with the Acid Rain Program began in 1995 and is now
90
in its seventh year. It has been a resounding success, with SO2
91
emissions from power generation dropping 4.5 million tons from 1990
92
levels and NOx emissions down 1.5 million tons from 1990 levels
93
(about 3 million tons lower than projected growth). In addition,
94
during the first Phase of the program (1995-1999), SO2 emissions
95
were between 20 to 30 percent below their allowable levels.
96
Furthermore, environmental monitoring networks tracked important
97
environmental improvements - - acid deposition was reduced by up to
98
30 percent in certain areas of the country.
99
And, these environmental improvements cost less than predicted
100
because of the built-in market based incentives. In 1990, EPA
101
projected the cost of full implementation of the SO2 emissions
102
reduction with trading at $5.7 billion per year (1997 dollars). In
103
1994, GAO projected the cost at $2.3 billion per year (1997
104
dollars). Recent estimates of annualized cost of compliance are in
105
the range of $1 to $1.5 billion per year at full
106
implementation.
107
President Bush has not only promised to take the SO2 trading
108
program to the next level but he has experience to lend to the
109
matter. In 1999, then-Governor Bush signed legislation that
110
permanently caps NOx and SO2 emissions from older power plants in
111
Texas starting in 2003 and requires utilities to install a certain
112
quantity of renewable and clean energy capacity by 2009.
113
Environmental Defense hailed this legislation as a model for the
114
country. The Emission Banking and Trading of Allowances Program is
115
expected to achieve substantial reductions when it is fully phased
116
in by 2003. It is estimated that this program will reduce NOx by
117
75,000 tons per year and SO2 by 35,000 tons per year. It is
118
designed to give the utilities flexibility in determining how and
119
where to achieve the reductions. Allowances are allocated to each
120
power plant based on 1997 emissions using a formula that does not
121
penalize the "clean" plants that already have a low NOx or SO2
122
emission rate. Permitted power generating plants may opt into the
123
trading program.
124
125
126
II. Regulating Emissions from Power Generation
127
The President's legislative approach stands in sharp contrast to
128
the complex web of existing regulations which currently confront
129
the industry. Over the years, Congress, EPA and the States have
130
responded to specific environmental and public health problems by
131
developing separate regulatory programs for utilities to address
132
the specific problems. Each individual program uses its own
133
approach to serve its own purpose. As I describe the different
134
regulatory programs, I think you will understand why we believe it
135
is time to simplify. If we have a new legislation that
136
significantly reduces emissions of SO2, NOx and mercury, we can
137
eliminate many of the individual programs that apply to the power
138
generation sector and replace them with a system that will reduce
139
the administrative burden on industry and governments, use
140
market-based incentives to keep compliance costs low, and provide
141
the industry with more certainty about its future regulatory
142
obligations.
143
There are many regulatory initiatives in place that will lead to
144
reductions in air emissions from electric power generation. These
145
regulations include both federal and State requirements that
146
address a variety of emissions including SO2, NOx, CO, PM10, and a
147
number of hazardous air pollutants. The requirements also vary
148
depending on the characteristics of the generating facility,
149
including its boiler type, size, age and location. These programs
150
include the National Ambient Air Quality Standards for particulate
151
matter and ozone, the section 126 and the NOx SIP Call rules, new
152
source review and new source performance standards, the regional
153
haze rule and mercury regulation as a hazardous air pollutant,
154
among others.
155
EPA has set national ambient air quality standards (NAAQS) for
156
six pollutants: ozone, carbon monoxide (CO); particulate matter
157
(PM); SO2; NO2; and lead (Pb). The Clean Air Act calls upon States
158
to adopt emissions control requirements in the form of State
159
Implementation Plans ("SIPs") to bring nonattainment areas into
160
compliance with the NAAQS. Historically, most States' strategies to
161
attain the SO2 and PM NAAQS included power plant controls.
162
EPA has taken two actions to address the contribution of
163
interstate transport of NOx emissions to downwind ozone
164
nonattainment problems, and both of these actions affect the power
165
sector. In 1998, EPA finalized the NOx SIP call, which now requires
166
19 states and the District of Columbia (whose emissions
167
significantly contribute to downwind ozone nonattainment problems)
168
to revise their SIPs to control summertime NOx emissions. In
169
response, all of these States are choosing control strategies that
170
focus on reducing power plant emissions. In a separate action aimed
171
at the same interstate NOx transport problem, in January 2000, EPA
172
finalized a rule which was issued in response to petitions from
173
several northeastern states under section 126 of the CAA. In this
174
rule, EPA found that emissions from large electric generating units
175
and large industrial boilers and turbines in 12 States and the
176
District of Columbia are significantly contributing to downwind
177
states' ozone nonattainment problems. The rule requires these
178
sources to control their summertime NOx emissions under the Federal
179
NOx Budget Trading Program beginning May 1, 2003.
180
The electric power generation sector is also regulated through a
181
variety of traditional and innovative programs. Consistent with the
182
Clean Air Act, many States have adopted NOx reasonably available
183
control technology requirements for combustion facilities. In
184
addition, several States have adopted market-based approaches. The
185
South Coast Air Quality Management District in Southern California,
186
for example, adopted a NOx and SO2 emissions trading program
187
(called RECLAIM). The Northeast and mid-Atlantic States that
188
comprise the Ozone Transport Region have developed a region-wide
189
NOx emissions trading program (the Ozone Transport Commission NOx
190
Budget Program). The revised ozone NAAQS and new PM2.5 NAAQS could
191
lead to further regulation of power plant SO2 emissions (a
192
precursor to ambient PM2.5) and NOx emissions (both for PM2.5 and
193
ozone attainment strategies).
194
The Act also requires State Implementation Plans to include a
195
preconstruction permit program for new or modified major stationary
196
sources, referred to as new source review ("NSR"). This program
197
ensures that when large, new facilities are built -- or major
198
modifications to existing facilities are made that result in a net
199
emissions increase -- they include state-of-the-art air pollution
200
control equipment. It also assures citizens who live near new major
201
sources of air pollution that the facilities will be as clean as
202
possible. The requirements are different for (1) the part of the
203
program called the Prevention of Significant Deterioration program
204
that applies to construction projects in areas where the air is
205
already clean, and (2) the part of the program called the
206
non-attainment NSR program that applies to construction projects in
207
areas where the air is unhealthy to breathe. For attainment areas,
208
to prevent significant deterioration of our nation's air quality,
209
new major sources and major modifications to existing sources must
210
apply the best available control technology and ensure that the new
211
pollution introduced into the environment does not adversely impact
212
the air quality, such as in pristine areas like national parks. For
213
nonattainment areas, in addition to applying control technology
214
that represents the lowest achievable emission rates, new major
215
sources and major modifications must offset their emissions
216
increases. This can be done by getting reductions from other
217
sources in the general area to compensate for the increases
218
resulting from the new air pollution sources.
219
The Act also requires EPA to establish new source performance
220
standards ("NSPS") that all new or modified sources must meet
221
regardless of their location. The NSPS are technology-based
222
numerical performance standards that apply to all sources in a
223
particular source category, such as electric utility steam
224
generating units or stationary gas turbines. These standards are
225
intended to "level the playing field" so that all new facilities
226
install a minimum amount of air pollution control equipment.
227
The recently finalized regional haze rule will also require
228
power generators to reduce SO2 and NOx emissions either through the
229
implementation of best available retrofit technology (BART) or a
230
trading program yet to be developed. States must show "reasonable
231
progress" in their state implementation plans toward the
232
congressionally mandated goal of returning to natural conditions in
233
national parks and wilderness areas.
234
EPA is developing a rule to limit mercury emissions from
235
utilities. The 1990 CAA Amendments required EPA to study and
236
prepare a report to Congress on the hazards to human health that
237
can reasonably be expected to occur as a result of emissions of
238
hazardous air pollutants (air toxics or HAPs) from fossil
239
fuel-fired electric power plants. Based on the Report to Congress
240
and on other available information, EPA found in December 2000 that
241
air toxics control is appropriate for coal-fired and oil-fired
242
utility boilers. As a result of that regulatory determination, EPA
243
is scheduled to propose "Maximum Achievable Control Technology"
244
(MACT) standards for these source categories by 2003. Given the
245
conclusions of the Report, the regulation is likely to focus on
246
mercury emissions.
247
The utility industry is also required to reduce SO2 emissions
248
through the Acid Rain Trading Program described above. In addition,
249
to address acid rain, the Clean Air Act requires utilities to
250
reduce their emissions through emissions limits, which EPA
251
established based on unit type.
252
253
254
III. Health and Environmental Benefits of the President's
255
Energy Plan
256
The President's Energy Plan recognizes that by conserving energy
257
and limiting NOx, SO2 and mercury emissions, we can provide the
258
country with significant public health and environmental benefits.
259
The problems we would address include: fine particle pollution,
260
visibility degradation, ozone pollution, mercury deposition, acid
261
rain, nitrate deposition and climate change. In turn, this will
262
avoid incidences of premature mortality, aggravation of respiratory
263
and cardiopulmonary illnesses, and diminished lung function which
264
results in lost work days, school absences and increased
265
hospitalizations and emergency room visits, and will also avoid
266
damage to eco-systems, fish and other wildlife. To understand the
267
tremendous benefits of the President's plan, we need to understand
268
the public health and environmental issues.
269
270
271
Emissions from Power Generation
272
Power generators are a significant source of three key
273
emissions: sulfur dioxide (SO2), nitrogen oxide (NOx), and mercury
274
(Hg). The Clean Air Act has been, and will continue to be, a
275
successful tool in reducing these emissions. However, while we are
276
observing significant environmental improvement, power generation
277
still contributes 67% of SO2, 25% of NOx, and 37% of man-made
278
mercury. (Power generation has other emissions, such as carbon
279
monoxide and coarse particles, but the level of these emissions
280
poses smaller risks for public health and the environment.)
281
One of the reasons power generation accounts for such a large
282
share of these key emissions is that significant emissions
283
reductions have already been required from other sources. For
284
example, a new car today is more than 90% cleaner than it was
285
before federal laws limiting emissions of CO, NOx and volatile
286
organic compounds - and they are subject to further reductions
287
starting in 2004, as are heavy duty trucks in 2007. In contrast,
288
some older power plants, built before certain Federal performance
289
standards were put into place, are still operating without modern
290
pollution control equipment for some emissions.
291
292
293
Air Quality Effects
294
FINE PARTICLE POLLUTION:
295
The President's Energy Plan will reduce fine particle pollution.
296
SO2 and NOx emissions from power generation react in the atmosphere
297
to form nitrates and sulfates, which are a substantial fraction of
298
fine particle (PM2.5) pollution. (Some PM2.5 comes from direct
299
emissions from a variety of sources.) A source emitting NOx and SO2
300
can cause PM2.5 many miles away. A substantial body of published
301
scientific literature recognizes a correlation between elevated
302
fine particulate matter and increased incidence of illness and
303
premature mortality. The health impacts include aggravation of
304
chronic bronchitis, hospitalizations due to cardio-respiratory
305
symptoms, emergency room visits due to aggravated asthma symptoms,
306
and acute respiratory symptoms. Based on these findings, EPA and
307
others estimate that attaining the fine particle standards would
308
avoid thousands, and up to tens of thousands, of premature deaths
309
annually.
310
The significant expansion in scientific research in recent years
311
has enhanced our understanding of the effects of particles on
312
health. EPA is summarizing all new information in the ongoing
313
review of the particulate matter standard in a "criteria document"
314
that will undergo extensive peer and public review.
315
• VISIBILITY AND REGIONAL HAZE IMPACTS:
316
The President's Energy Plan will improve visibility by reducing
317
SO2 and NOx emissions. Sulfates and nitrates that form in the
318
atmosphere from SO2 and NOx emissions are significant contributors
319
to visibility impairment in many national parks and wilderness
320
areas, as well as urban areas across the country. Sulfates are a
321
key factor in all areas of the United States, particularly in the
322
East, where high humidity increases the light extinction efficiency
323
of sulfates. Sulfates are responsible for 6080% of total light
324
extinction in the East, based on data collected during the 1990's
325
in eastern national parks such as Acadia, Everglades, Great Smoky
326
Mountains, Shenandoah, and in Washington, DC.
327
In the West, sulfates account for approximately 25-50% of
328
visibility impairment. Nitrates can play a larger role in
329
visibility problems in some portions of the West than in the East.
330
For example, nitrates account for 20-40% of visibility impairment
331
in national parks and wilderness areas in Southern California. In
332
many urban areas, NOx emissions from cars, trucks, and power plants
333
contribute to winter time "brown cloud" situations.
334
335
C OZONE:
336
The President's Energy Plan will reduce ozone by reducing NOx, a
337
key contributor to the formation of ground-level ozone. In the
338
presence of sunlight, NOx and volatile organic compounds react
339
photochemically to produce ozone. NOx can be transported long
340
distances and contribute to ozone many hundreds of miles from its
341
source. More than 97 million people live in areas that do not yet
342
meet the health-based 1-hour ozone standard (based on 1997-1999
343
data). The number would be even higher for the new 8-hour ozone
344
standard. Reducing ozone levels will result in fewer
345
hospitalizations, emergency room and doctors visits for asthmatics,
346
significantly fewer incidents of lung inflamation for atrisk
347
populations, and significantly fewer incidents of moderate to
348
severe respiratory symptoms in children.
349
Not only will reducing ozone provide public health benefits, but
350
it will avoid damage to ecosystems and vegetation. Ozone causes
351
decreased agricultural and commercial forest yields, increased
352
mortality and reduced growth of tree seedlings, and increased plant
353
susceptibility to disease, pests, and environmental stresses (e.g.,
354
harsh weather). Since NOx emissions result in formation of
355
ground-level ozone, reducing NOx emissions will reduce ozone levels
356
and thus reduce the deleterious effects of ozone on human health
357
and ecosystems.
358
Deposition Effects
359
360
361
C MERCURY:
362
The President's Energy Plan will benefit public health by
363
reducing mercury air emissions. Mercury is highly toxic in small
364
quantities and Americans with diets with high levels of mercury are
365
at risk for adverse health effects. Mercury is a naturally
366
occurring element, but human activity mobilizes mercury in the
367
environment, making it more bioavailable. After mercury is emitted
368
to the air, it can be transported through the atmosphere for days
369
to years before being deposited into water bodies.
370
Once mercury is deposited in lakes, rivers, and oceans, it
371
bioaccumulates in the food chain, resulting in high concentrations
372
in predatory fish. In the U.S., most human exposure to mercury is
373
the result of consumption of fish contaminated with methylmercury.
374
A recent report of the National Academy of Sciences (NAS) concluded
375
that while most Americans face a very low risk from methylmercury,
376
children of women who consume large amounts of fish during
377
pregnancy face a much higher risk. Fetuses are particularly
378
vulnerable to methylmercury because of their rapidly developing
379
nervous systems. These effects include cognitive, sensory, and
380
motor deficits. The NAS study estimates as many as 60,000 children
381
annually may develop neurological problems because of low-level
382
methylmercury exposure through their mother prior to birth.
383
Forty-one states have advisories warning the public to restrict
384
eating fish from local waters due to methylmercury. EPA estimates
385
that 5.6 million acres of lakes, estuaries and wetlands and 43,500
386
miles of streams, rivers and coasts are impaired by mercury
387
emissions.
388
ACID RAIN:
389
The President's Energy Plan will reduce acid rain by reducing
390
SO2 and NOx. Acidic deposition or "acid rain" occurs when SO2 and
391
NOx in the atmosphere react with water, oxygen, and oxidants to
392
form acidic compounds. These compounds fall to the Earth in either
393
dry form (gas and particles) or wet form (rain, snow, and fog).
394
Some are carried by the wind, sometimes hundreds of miles, across
395
state and national borders. In the United States, about 67 percent
396
of annual SO2 emissions and 25 percent of NOx emissions are
397
produced by electric utility plants that burn fossil fuels.
398
Although we have made progress as a result of the 1990 Acid Rain
399
Program, we have not fully addressed the problem. Indicators of
400
recovery of lakes and streams do not show consistent change in
401
response to reduced SO2 emissions. In sensitive areas such as the
402
Adirondacks, for example, the majority of lakes have remained
403
fairly constant in terms of acidification levels, while the most
404
sensitive lakes continue to acidify. Overall, acid deposition
405
continues to impair the water quality of lakes and streams in the
406
Northeast: 41 percent of lakes in the Adirondack region of New York
407
and 15 percent of lakes in New England exhibit signs of chronic
408
and/or episodic acidification. Although sulfur deposition has
409
declined, nitrogen emissions have not changed substantially
410
region-wide. Moreover, recent findings also suggest that nitrogen
411
is quantitatively as important or, in some areas, possibly more
412
important than sulfur as a cause of episodic acidification because
413
of short-term acidic pulses occurring during the most biologically
414
sensitive time of the year, when fish reproduce. Reductions of NOx,
415
particularly during winter and spring, are critical for addressing
416
these concerns.
417
� NITROGEN DEPOSITION:
418
The President's Energy Plan will improve eco-systems and water
419
bodies by reducing NOx emissions. Some air emissions of NOx from
420
power generation result in deposition of nitrogen in soils and
421
water. While nitrogen is an essential nutrient, its availability is
422
naturally limited, making it an important factor in regulating the
423
structure and functioning of both terrestrial and aquatic
424
ecological systems. Human activity has greatly altered the
425
terrestrial and atmospheric nitrogen cycle, doubling the annual
426
amount of nitrogen available in forms that are useful to living
427
organisms. Nitrogen saturation of watersheds contributes to
428
environmental problems such as reduced drinking water quality,
429
nitrateinduced toxic effects on freshwater organisms, increased
430
soil acidification and aluminum mobility, increased emissions from
431
soil of nitrogenous greenhouse trace gases, reduction of methane
432
consumption in soil, and forest decline and reduced
433
productivity.
434
Coastal water and marine environment are also impacted by
435
atmospheric deposition of nitrogen. Depending upon the location,
436
from 10 to more than 40 percent of new nitrogen inputs to coastal
437
waters along the East Coast and Gulf Coast of the United States
438
come from air pollution. One of the best documented and understood
439
impacts of increased nitrogen is the eutrophication of estuaries
440
and coastal waters. Eutrophication refers to the increase in the
441
rate of supply of organic matter to an ecosystem and its many
442
undesirable consequences. Symptoms of eutrophication are found in
443
many of our nation's coastal ecosystems. They include algal blooms
444
that are potentially hazardous to human health, low dissolved
445
oxygen concentrations, declines in the health of fish and shellfish
446
populations, loss of seagrass beds and coral reefs, and ecological
447
changes in food webs.
448
449
450
451
Summary of Health and Environmental Effects
452
Adopting a unified approach to reduce SO2, NOx and mercury is
453
better than looking at each pollutant separately because of
454
synergistic effects. Beyond their impacts as separate emissions,
455
SO2, NOx, and mercury together contribute to many air
456
pollution-related problems affecting human health and the
457
environment. In certain cases, synergies exist between emissions
458
and among the various reduction approaches available, making it
459
imperative that efforts to reduce risk address all three emissions
460
accommodate these synergies. In the case of fine particles,
461
atmospheric chemical relationships suggest that when only reducing
462
sulfate for example, it is replaced in the atmosphere by nitrate.
463
Thus, simultaneous NOx and SO2 emission reductions are critical. In
464
the case of acid rain, significant reductions in sulfur dioxide
465
have not corresponded to ecological changes due to continuing high
466
levels of nitrogen. Continuing levels of sulfur deposition, albeit
467
smaller than before, also work to prevent recovery due to extremely
468
large sulfur loadings over the years. Both emissions count in
469
achieving the goal of recovery. Additionally, some synergies have
470
been observed between methylmercury and lake acidity - the more
471
acidic, the greater the mercury concentration.
472
As more environmental data become available and science
473
improves, we are observing some environmental improvement
474
accompanying the downward trend in emissions. However, there are
475
persistent and growing concerns regarding recovery of ecosystems
476
and the risks that air pollution pose to human health. For
477
instance, nitrate levels in surface waters are not significantly
478
improving, and at best are constant. Logically, if emissions
479
continue at the same level, or increase, pollution problems will
480
mirror that trend. Visibility impairment in national parks,
481
wilderness areas and urban areas also continues to be a problem.
482
Many people continue to be exposed to unacceptable levels of smog.
483
Of particular significance --the American public has become acutely
484
aware of the hazards to their health, including the risk of
485
mortality, posed by inhalation of fine particles and exposure to
486
mercury through fish consumption.
487
488
489
IV Climate Change
490
The President's Energy Plan, and the climate change strategy
491
that is under development, will provide benefits by addressing
492
climate change. Energy-related activities are the primary source of
493
U.S. man-made greenhouse gas emissions. Power generators, which
494
emit CO2, contribute abut 29% of the total emissions of all U.S.
495
man-made greenhouse gases. Scientists continue to learn more about
496
global climate change, its causes, potential impacts, and possible
497
solution. We recently held Cabinet-level working group meetings to
498
review the most recent, most accurate and most comprehensive
499
science. During those meetings, we heard from scientists offering a
500
wide spectrum of views. We have reviewed the facts and listened to
501
many theories and suppositions. The working group asked the highly
502
respected National Academy of Sciences to provide us the most
503
up-to-date information about what is known and about what is not
504
known on the science of climate change.
505
We know the surface temperature of the Earth is warming. It has
506
risen by .6 degrees Celsius over the past 100 years. There was a
507
warming trend from the 1890s to the 1940s, cooling from the 1940s
508
to the 1970s, and then sharply rising temperatures from the 1970s
509
to today. There is a natural greenhouse effect that contributes to
510
warming. Greenhouse gases trap heat and thus warm the Earth because
511
they prevent a significant portion of infrared radiation from
512
escaping into space. Concentration of greenhouse gases, especially
513
CO2, have increased substantially since the beginning of the
514
industrial revolution. And the National Academy of Sciences
515
indicates that the increase is due in large part to human activity.
516
The Academy's report also tells us that there are many unanswered
517
questions about climate change, which makes it difficult to
518
determine what levels of greenhouse gas emissions need to be
519
avoided.
520
To address global climate change and greenhouse gas emissions,
521
we are pursuing a broad array of conservation and energy efficiency
522
goals under the Administration's National Energy Policy as well as
523
the development of a comprehensive policy under the ongoing
524
cabinet-level review for this issue. On June 11, President Bush
525
announced the establishment of two major initiatives to address the
526
major scientific and technological challenges presented by this
527
serious, long-term issue: the U.S. Climate Research Initiative and
528
the National Climate Change Technology Initiative. In addition, he
529
committed the United States to increasing cooperative efforts in
530
the Western Hemisphere, and with our allies globally, to
531
aggressively pursue joint research and actions. These efforts have
532
recently borne fruit, particularly recent agreements with Japan and
533
Italy to collaborate on climate modeling efforts and with El
534
Salvador in a "forest for debt" swap that will preserve tropical
535
forests there that sequester carbon. The complex challenge of
536
global climate change requires a global response that will draw on
537
the power of global markets and the promise of technology to
538
achieve emissions reductions most flexibly and costeffectively in
539
the coming century. The Administration intends to address this
540
challenge in that context, and will leverage our national resources
541
to enhance our scientific understanding of global climate change,
542
and develop the advanced energy technologies that the world will
543
need in coming decades to meet its energy and environmental
544
needs.
545
546
547
V. Conclusion
548
Our country has made great progress in reducing air pollution
549
over the last several decades, but pollution from power generation
550
needs to be further controlled. We can draw no other conclusion
551
given the significant contribution that power generation makes to
552
the emissions that cause such serious public health and
553
environmental problems.
554
But our current regulatory programs are not the most efficient
555
way to achieve the goal of ensuring a reliable energy supply in an
556
environmentally responsible manner. Rather than take a
557
pollutant-by-pollutant, problem-by-problem approach, we have the
558
opportunity to examine the sector as a whole. Doing so provides us
559
with the opportunity for cost-effective reductions and significant
560
public health and environmental gains. That is why this
561
Administration supports the development of new legislation that
562
builds on the success of the market-based Acid Rain Program to
563
reduce significantly the SO2, NOx and mercury emissions from power
564
generation. Mandatory controls are not the only way to solve public
565
health and environmental problems. President Bush's National Energy
566
Plan also includes measures to increase conservation of energy,
567
increase energy efficiency, and encourage technological advances
568
such as clean coal technology, fuel cells, and combined heat and
569
power facilities -- all of which will contribute to addressing the
570
energy and environmental challenges of
571
11
572
this industry.
573
I have already spent time with representatives of the power
574
generation sector and have heard from a number of them who are
575
interested in legislation that will provide the public health and
576
environmental benefits we discussed today. I applaud their concern
577
and their willingness to help craft a workable solution. I have
578
also heard from environmentalists who are interested in these same
579
issues. I know that many of you are interested in addressing these
580
issues through legislation. I hope that our common interests will
581
lead us to a consensus - one that will provide the country with
582
significant benefits. I look forward to working with you on these
583
issues.
584
12
585
586
587
588
589