Book a Demo!
CoCalc Logo Icon
StoreFeaturesDocsShareSupportNewsAboutPoliciesSign UpSign In
Download
29550 views
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
okay have you ever served as a juror
8
9
10
never i've never been served on the jury never been called up in a jury although some of my friends have been jurors
11
12
13
uh-huh
14
i never have either
15
16
17
you haven't huh if you were uh what do you think about the whole concept of a trial by your peers
18
19
20
well i think it's a good idea i think our justice system needs a major overhaul and i'm not sure what needs to be done to fix it but i think they've got a lot of problems
21
22
23
i think the major thing they need to correct is how long it takes something to get to jury and to get to trial
24
25
26
true
27
28
29
and i don't know if that's just a pure volumes number or or what but uh
30
sometimes i think the jury is ignorant in the facts of law and how things should be determined and they're too easily swayed by their emotion
31
32
33
yeah i think that's true
34
35
36
hence is possible error as you can see in all the ironsides
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
TV shows
44
45
46
yeah do you would you prefer all trials by a judge
47
48
49
no i think there are certain things that uh the jury can determine as far as uh guilty or not guilty but as far as the affixing affixing affixing of punishment and fines and things of that nature
50
i don't know if that is best left up to the jury to decide to award you know two point two million dollar kind of settlement versus a judge knowing you know it's true that you know this may be sad and all that thing but uh
51
the jury i think is best in most cases suited for determination of guilt and innocence but not the award of of penalties and fines and punishment
52
53
54
yeah i would agree with that i think you're right i think they sometimes get carried away by the circumstances and make huge settlements thinking well it's only going to cost the insurance company and
55
56
57
um-hum
58
that's true but uh i do like the idea of the jury being the the the people who decide in the matter of uh if it's a jail term versus life and death
59
60
61
uh-huh
62
63
64
you know the death penalty and such
65
66
67
if they give them all the information i don't know when it comes to sentencing phase i guess they tell them if a guy if the person has a previous record and stuff
68
69
70
uh-huh
71
72
73
sometimes it seems like during the trial part the jury's not you know misses some of the best evidence because they make them leave and
74
75
76
right
77
78
79
the judge decides whether or not they should hear it
80
81
82
yeah uh it it it's kind of difficult and i guess the whole system is set up to rather let uh some guilty people go free than to put an innocent person in in jail
83
84
85
right
86
87
88
although you still hear about those occasionally
89
90
91
yeah
92
do you think the verdict should be completely unanimous by the jury
93
94
95
um i don't know i you know i heard a very interesting and maybe it's just the TV show or movie i was watching they were going through a trial
96
and i think it was like on one of the the documentary TV shows where they ask for the the verdict by the jury
97
98
99
uh-huh
100
101
102
and they went by each one saying guilty or innocent guilty or innocent
103
104
105
uh-huh
106
107
108
and they took it more as just like a majority
109
110
111
oh
112
113
114
so i i
115
116
117
some of them disagree i mean some of them said one way and some the other
118
119
120
exactly but they took you know whatever the majority was so i didn't know if that was just something for drama or that's truly the way it is i always thought it had to be unanimous
121
122
123
i think it does have to be unanimous
124
125
126
but uh
127
rather interesting
128
129
130
i know they can poll a jury make sure everybody agrees with what they said the verdict was but
131
i thought that they all had to agree or else they it was a hung jury
132
133
134
uh-huh i did i did also
135
136
137
and
138
yeah i think i don't know how i feel about that i think maybe uh
139
majority might be sufficient
140
141
142
143
144
uh-huh
145
146
147
it's hard to say though i
148
149
150
what about in international
151
trials do you think they should have a jury there i think that would be kind of interesting
152
153
154
oh
155
yeah i hadn't thought about international trials at all
156
157
158
i guess the the problem with that is there's no true authority in any kind of international verdicts
159
160
161
right
162
163
164
like you know the old day with the rack we they're going to say okay you're guilty and you have to pay Kuwait four million dollars well whose going to really make them
165
166
167
yeah
168
169
170
nobody
171
172
173
yeah
174
175
176
so
177
but i think it would be kind of interesting to incorporate that concept of you know people from different countries
178
uh in as international law also
179
180
181
yeah i think maybe they'd need to be more knowledgeable though than just your average Joe off the street
182
183
184
um-hum
185
186
187
for something like that because of the cultural differences
188
189
190
right
191
192
193
things like that
194
195
196
i don't know how what it would take to be come up with a true perfect
197
system or if one exists but
198
199
200
yeah what about uniform sentencing
201
202
203
uh is that the crime and it's already false due to some chart and determine the punishment or
204
205
206
right yeah like if you're convicted of a certain crime you automatically get so many years it's not a discretionary thing
207
208
209
um-hum i think there should be a core minimum that they get but uh
210
211
212
213
214
215
216
i guess there should be some flexibility because every situation may be unique that the judge can either increase that or keep it just at its minimum things of that nature
217
218
219
yeah
220
221
222
i
223
224
225
i wish that when they sentence someone if they're going to sentence him to five years then make him serve five years
226
227
228
yeah that serves a kind of if they're i guess uh if you sentence someone to life life is only forty nine years something like that
229
230
231
you know
232
yeah i
233
234
235
and i guess you're eligible after twenty seven for parole even though you're in for life
236
237
238
yeah and sometimes those people are are young enough they can still get out and cause a lot of trouble
239
240
241
yeah although i guess it's your you want them to rehabilitate and become better rather than sitting in there and being a drain all the time
242
243
244
yeah i don't believe that very often happens
245
246
247
no because uh inside the jail there i don't think there's no real rehabilitation it just
248
249
250
i don't think so either In fact i think they end up worse because the conditions are so bad
251
252
253
yes it's another war zone
254
255
256
yeah
257
258
259
but
260
who knows
261
262
263
i think i think maybe they ought to just be punished with some some kind of real punishment like hard labor for a shorter length of time you know actually make them do something that's not pleasant
264
265
266
i agree get them out there
267
268
269
and do it and get it over with and get back in the you know world and not spend so much time sitting around letting the bad influences of the other ones rub off on them and
270
271
272
sure they should have them go out and doing stuff cleaning up or picking up dirt or weeds or who knows what something for the for the state since the state is paying for them they should get some kind of kind of work out of them
273
274
275
yeah
276
yeah something besides license plates and tiddlywinks
277
278
279
exactly
280
281
282
yeah
283
284
285
trading their lives for cigarettes
286
287
288
yeah
289
290
291
those kinds of things
292
well good
293
294
295
well i think that covers it
296
297
298
i think so
299
300
301
it was nice talking to you
302
303
304
nice talking to you also
305
306
307
um bye
308
309
310
have a wonderful Easter
311
312
313
you too bye
314
315
316
bye
317
318
319
320
321
322
323
324
325
326