Book a Demo!
CoCalc Logo Icon
StoreFeaturesDocsShareSupportNewsAboutPoliciesSign UpSign In
Download
29548 views
1
2
3
4
5
to uh trial by jury and whether it works or not is
6
7
8
9
10
hey i like the current system
11
12
13
yeah i expect it's um about as good as one can expect um
14
i suppose you get an illogical verdict now and then but uh
15
16
17
yeah yeah i figure the answer to that is to educate the consumers or the uh
18
19
20
the
21
the jurors you mean the people
22
23
24
right just
25
26
27
yeah i just got called to my first jury duty uh-huh
28
i never been on a jury how about you
29
30
31
hey
32
two weeks ago
33
first time i was ever called
34
35
36
and were you did you did you show up and do it or whatever it was
37
38
39
oh yeah i showed up but uh the case settled before they could uh
40
make us uh actually listen to anything so i have no idea what the case was about or uh you know i didn't get to do anything
41
42
43
my brother was on some real complex business case where they were um
44
decide to asked to decide the exact amount to the penny of fraud in some credit card case you know
45
46
47
wait so the jury had to like go over
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
ledgers and financial records and
55
56
57
well they went over it in the trial but they didn't give the stuff to the jury afterward it was really bizarre uh
58
59
60
wait a second don't
61
don't they have to enter that in as evidence and can't the jury request any piece of it
62
63
64
yeah but they have to ask for it and then the the bailiff brings it and they can look at it then the bailiff takes it away again it's not like they can just spread it out in their jury room and then you know get out a bunch of calculators and pocket computers and add it all up it was
65
66
67
right the the jurors request an IBM three seventy
68
69
70
yeah right would you give me an IDMS IDMS system or something like that dear judge
71
72
73
74
75
76
77
you know it was it was a very peculiar case i guess that one was didn't work very well um uh but
78
79
80
whoa that i'm not sure that's the jury's fault
81
82
83
no no i don't think so either um
84
85
86
but i don't know what else they could've done
87
88
89
yeah yeah um i guess i guess nothing else but uh
90
91
92
TI suggests just giving it to the judge but uh
93
94
95
well
96
for sentencing i don't know does that make any sense i mean
97
it depends on what i i don't know what the offense is i guess that's why we have juries is to take each case on a case by case basis and that's fine
98
anyway um
99
100
101
no i mean the jury
102
there's problems with it as far as finding jurors as far as weird verdicts
103
as far as just the timing the timing you know it takes a lot of time
104
but uh
105
you know i like it because i think
106
you don't have the abuse or it's a sort of a check
107
if you have one guy doing something he can sort of
108
go out of control and it's a long time before he gets reigned in
109
110
111
yeah or if it's an organizational problem you know where where you know the
112
113
114
and he can do a lot of damage
115
116
117
you know it's possible to imagine a corrupt judicial system where you know all the judges are are
118
part of the system i guess that happened in Chicago once huh
119
120
121
yeah
122
yeah
123
124
125
126
127
128
129
or just even one guy just before you get a chance to uh
130
you know to uh purge him
131
he could do a lot of damage
132
133
134
yeah yeah i guess they do anyway i guess
135
the only trouble with the jury system i see is it's really darned darned expensive and and you know time consuming and
136
you know and and all these systems of where you can like
137
ask a jury ask each juror what they think about something then kick them out and
138
you know i guess they can manipulate it a little
139
140
141
you know maybe some of the uh
142
like the hype
143
needs to be cut out
144
but you mention expense
145
146
147
yeah
148
149
150
i think you get what you pay for
151
152
153
yeah it's true no lie
154
155
156
you know if you want a cheap legal system you're you're gonna get that kind of
157
Kmart service or uh
158
well Kmart's not all that bad
159
160
161
162
163
164
165
there's got to be some sort of cheap
166
what's the epitome of cheap these days
167
168
169
beats me um
170
yeah in in Massachusetts it's the judicial system their buildings are all falling down
171
172
173
174
175
176
177
well i guess that gets them the sample
178
good night sir
179
180
181
all right good luck
182
183
184
take it easy
185
186
187
188
189
190
191
192
193
194